Sharing and building Solution Focused practice in organisations

Switch - what Chip & Dan Heath's new book adds to the SF repertoire

Switch – How to change things when change is hard

Chip & Dan Heath

This is a curious book. Its strength is its collection of wonderful stories, clearly and simply told. They are drawn from politics, organisations and individuals – something to appeal to everybody.

And there is much to cheer those of us who have been taking a solutions-focused (SF) view of change, with a great deal of the book consisting of the Heaths’ efforts to put familiar concepts, tools and techniques into snappier, stickier language (with varying degrees of joy).

They advocate looking for what works and doing more of it. ‘Don’t obsess about the failures. Instead, investigate and clone the successes,’ they say. Drawing explicitly from SF and Positive Deviance, they have us identify ‘bright spots’. A vision of a future is termed a ‘destination postcard’. Illustrating small actions and a direct route, they report a successful health campaign that told people to reach for a jug of 1% milk instead of whole milk. They note that visible success prompts people to join in.

Their most powerful metaphor, borrowed from positive psychologist J Haidt, is the Rider and the Elephant. These represent respectively the conscious mind and the subconscious, in the tradition of Plato’s charioteer and chariot. ‘Changes often fail because the Rider simply can’t keep the Elephant on the road long enough to reach the destination.’ Big changes can sap our exhaustible reserves of self-control – and the old habits kick back in. It’s a neat way to highlight impact and sustainability – twin grails familiar to organisational change consultants, and they have plenty of ideas for engaging both parties.

I particularly enjoyed their brutal dismissal of ‘knowledge’ and ‘attitudes’ as keys to change, in favour of interactional elements. Smaller containers for food mean people will eat less. It’s easier here to change the situation than change the people, they report, echoing our conclusions in The Solutions Focus – Making Coaching and Change Simple (

They are clearly pragmatists at heart. ‘For anyone to change, someone has to start acting differently,’ they note, and they have grasped the kernel of SF in at least some of their case study descriptions. They highlight the value of knowing what’s wanted, not what isn’t, even in cases of violent parenting, and note that the solutions (better behaviour from the child, more caring involvement from the parent) have no logical connections to the problems (violent behaviour to the child).

Without ever quite saying it, they get it: solutions consist of improved interactions. ‘Just look for a strong beginning and a strong ending and get moving,’ they advise. Which brings us to the curiosity: their model, which gets more elaborate chapter by chapter, seems weaker than those they have drawn upon. The milk story, for example, contains the vital ingredient of a well-chosen small action, yet still has people being told what to do. A solution-focused coach would keep the clarity of the small step, but prefer to have actions generated by people for themselves.

And their account is far from simple. They even contradict themselves when their analysis says we need to change not only the situation, but also hearts and mind, rather flying in the face of their food portion example.

Anyone who knows SF will see endless parallels with the puzzlingly unacknowledged SF work in organisations – puzzling because their strength as writers and journalists is presumably research (and they have many great examples to illustrate their points). They have found SF as therapy and they visit other stops on the landscape of positive change – including mentions of Appreciative Inquiry, Positive Psychology and Marcus Buckingham’s strengths gang. Yet no mention, for example, of SOL - - the network for sharing and building solution-focused practice in organisations.

Less surprisingly, the equally relevant but less-well-known field of Applied Improvisation is not mentioned at all, although its primary concepts are touched upon. ‘You can’t script every move’, say Chip and Dan. You can apparently script all the critical moves, though one might wonder how you are going to know all those in advance. ‘Use what you’ve got’, they improvisationally advise, commenting on a railroad transformation story.

So, I’m not sure if Switch does much to advance the philosophy or pragmatics of SF, though it may well work wonders for the marketing.

Views: 130

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of SOLWorld to add comments!

Join SOLWorld

Comment by Rodney Daut on May 11, 2010 at 23:24
@Paul Z Jackson That's a very good question you ask. Perhaps those of you who have websites could write your own reviews of the book Switch. This will help you get some free search engine traffic for people who look for the name of the book online.
Comment by Hans-Peter Korn on May 3, 2010 at 16:53
Yes, Paul, interesting! And some weeks ago there was an interesting discussion about it here:
Comment by Paul Z Jackson on March 30, 2010 at 20:56
How can we apply ourselves to take advantage of the Heath's interest in our kind of work?




Jumpstart into Solution Focus

You want to learn more about "Solution Focus"?

You prefer a "step by step" introduction instead to start with reading some
voluminous books?

You would appreciate to have a complete "helicopter view" on SF after the first step…


Created by Hans-Peter Korn Dec 25, 2009 at 10:25am. Last updated by Mark McKergow Nov 3, 2014.

Making the most of

If you’ve just arrived at (the SOLWorld ning group), you may be looking at all the features and wondering where to start.  This note might be helpful…



Created by Mark McKergow Jun 3, 2008 at 4:55pm. Last updated by Jesper H Christiansen Aug 22, 2017.

Open Space at SOLworld conferences

SOLworld Open Space instructions as it was used at the 2011 conference, by Mark McKergow


Created by Katalin Hankovszky Dec 30, 2015 at 10:18pm. Last updated by Katalin Hankovszky Dec 30, 2015.

SOLWorld Resources

Welcome to the SOLWorld Resources section.  This part of the site features information about the SOLWorld network, our past events and materials from our previous website.  It will take some time to update all the information, so thanks for your patience. 

Information in this part of the site is 'read-only'.  If you want to start discussions, please go to the Forum or Groups. …


Created by Mark McKergow May 12, 2008 at 4:08pm. Last updated by Hans-Peter Korn Dec 25, 2009.

© 2022   Created by Mark McKergow.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service